Treatment of journalists at anti-fracking protest raises concern

By | October 23, 2013 at 3:57 pm | 5 comments | News

PEN Canada’s National Affairs Committee is concerned with the wrongful treatment of journalists during recent anti-fracking protests at Elsipogtog, NB, particularly the arrest of Halifax Media Co-op journalist Miles Howe who was arrested while taking pictures on Oct. 17. The RCMP twice reduced charges against Howe before finally releasing him with no charges.

“No one in Canada may be arrested for the simple act of photographing or filming in public places or on private property that is open to the public,” said William Kowalski, Chair of PEN Canada’s National Affairs Committee.

PEN Canada is also concerned that journalists from several news outlets had their equipment confiscated temporarily by protesters at Elsipogtog. Journalists and others have the right to photograph or film without unreasonable or illegal interference. Journalists must be free to do their work without harassment, intimidation, or fear of reprisal.

Our constitution explicitly protects freedom of the press and other media of communication as essential elements of freedom of expression.


Filming and photography rights
PEN Canada has taken an active interest in public photography and filming rights. This is of particular concern given recent examples of the infringement on these rights.

  • During the G20 protests that took place in Toronto in 2010, a number of journalists had their equipment confiscated and were subjected to aggressive crowd dispersal techniques.
  • In 2012, while searching a home, police prevented neighbours from filming them and confiscated the homeowners’ cellphones so they could not take pictures.
  • In June 2013, Toronto Star photographer Alex Consiglio was arrested for trespassing while taking pictures of an injured GO Transit officer at Union Station in Toronto.

Full text on these cases available here.
Pocketbook guide to photography and filming rights available here.

PEN Canada
PEN Canada is a nonpartisan organization of writers that works with others to defend freedom of expression as a basic human right at home and abroad. PEN Canada promotes literature, fights censorship, helps free persecuted writers from prison, and assists writers living in exile in Canada.

For further information:Juanita Bawagan
(416) 703-8448 ext. 21


  1. Robert Blanchrad (3 years ago)

    A lot of questions ares not answered and withe the Living Tycoon media, we are in danger of been mussel an manipulated: scary time here!

  2. Sarah Smith (2 years ago)

    “…had their equipment confiscated temporarily by protesters at Elsipogtog.” This is a bit misleading, isn’t it? In everything I’ve read about the Elsipogtog conflict, it’s been said that the police, not the protesters, confiscated the reporters’ equipment.

    • PENCanada (2 years ago)

      Hello Sarah, thank you for your comment. The specific case we were referring to in the line you quoted was that of Global news reporter Laura Brown. PEN Canada expressed concern over her case and the treatment of journalists by the RCMP.

  3. All you tell are lies!: Elsipogtog and the failure of the media | Bones for War (2 years ago)

    […] fact, not 40 protestors arrested that day but 39 and one journalist—a worrying event about which PEN Canada expressed concern. (PEN also expressed concern over the later intimidation of the […]

  4. Media Co-Op reporter Miles Howe arrested three times at fracking protest (2 years ago)

    […] More information: Media Co-op – Journalist Miles Howe Arrested in Elsipogtog, Arrested for the third time for covering shale gas protests – here Pen Canada – Treatment of journalists at anti-fracking protest raises concern – here […]


You must be logged in to post a comment.

© PEN Canada 2013 · 24 Ryerson Ave., Suite 301, Toronto ON M5T 2P3 · Phone: 416 703 8448 · Fax: 416 703 3870
· Charitable Business Number 88916 2541 RR0001